Jim Brandstatter is one of us.
And I thought someone should stand up for him. He is a Detroit sports fan. He wore the maize and blue of Michigan football and he is every bit a key fabric of Detroit as anybody. He is so Detroit that I used to go to my local super market and purchase a chicken salad named after him. What WJR did to the man was unnecessary and uncalled for.
The station fired one of us for the sake of “going in a different direction.” In other words the people that run the station did not have a good reason to fire him. Their thinking is he’s done it long enough so let’s try new juice for the hell of it.
He’s old (68) so people will understand.
Isn’t this the same station that fired Ernie Harwell? I guess Brady should not feel so bad. He is in good company.
They will pump up Brandstatter’s replacement Lomas Brown, but my guess is Lomas will be no better than Brandstatter. He will just be a different voice. He’s not going to give us exciting insight when the team goes sour because that is not what local broadcasters do in Detroit.
Case in point came earlier this week when Nick Castellanos, who is a butcher in the outfield, received no criticism on FS Detroit when he lost a fly ball in the roof of Tropicana Field. He didn’t even get a light tap on the wrist for costing the Tigers four runs during a 10-9 10th inning defeat.
I liked Brandstatter in the booth for Lions games. What I didn’t like were the apologetic post game interviews with coaches and players. I doubt that we will get hard hitting post game interviews from Brown either.
I liked Jim Brandstatter as color man for Michigan football, but his play by play calls are not compelling or captivating.
Everybody who knows him will tell you that Brandstatter is a good man with a good heart. But that’s not the issue here. Was he a good broadcaster? The answer is yes.
Were fans clamoring to have him fired? The answer is no.
Brandstatter took the high road and did not thrown flames at WJR after his firing. He was blind sided like the rest of us. Now he can enjoy his Sunday’s and does not have to catch ungodly early morning flights after Saturday Michigan football games to catch up with the Lions on Sunday. This could turn out to be a blessing for him.